N-acetylcysteine bests fenoldopam against contrast-induced nephropathy
Mon, 16 Aug 2004 19:00:00 | Shelley Wood

Naples and Milan, Italy - Driving another nail into the fenoldopam coffin, a new study shows that the drug, approved for the treatment of hypertension, is ineffective at preventing contrast-induced nephropathy. This latest information comes from an Italian randomized trial comparing fenoldopam mesylate to N-acetylcysteine (NAC) in patients with renal insufficiency undergoing coronary or peripheral procedures.

As Dr Carlo Briguori (Vita e Salute University School of Medicine, Milan, Italy) and colleagues note, fenoldopam is a dopamine-1 receptor agonist that has been hypothesized to prevent renal vasoconstriction through peripheral vasodilation. By contrast, NAC is an antioxidant believed to preserve renal function by scavenging reactive oxygen that could otherwise lead to tissue damage. As previously reported by heartwire, the results of the Controlled Multicenter Trial Evaluating Fenoldopam Mesylate for the Prevention of Contrast-Induced Nephropathy (CONTRAST), comparing fenoldopam with placebo, showed that fenoldopam was no better than hydration alone at reducing contrast-induced nephropathy. Now, Briguori et al's study, appearing in the August 18, 2004 issue of the Journal of the American College of Cardiology, reaffirms the CONTRAST findings by stacking fenoldopam against NAC.1

"Although preliminary studies suggest that the administration of fenoldopam protects against [contrast-agent-associated nephrotoxicity], our finding confirms the results of the recent CONTRAST trial," Briguori et al write.


A strategy to be dropped

Their study randomized 192 patients to saline plus NAC or fenoldopam before and after nonionic iso-osmolality contrast dye. They report that contrast-induced nephropathy occurred in more of the fenoldopam patients than in the NAC patients, a statistically significant difference. Fenoldopam also showed a trend toward worse outcomes in various subgroups.

"According to these findings and considering the high cost of this drug, a strategy of hydration plus fenoldopam mesylate should not be used as a prophylactic measure to prevent contrast-agent-associated nephropathy," the authors conclude.

Incidence of contrast-induced nephrotoxicity

Patient group

Fenoldopam (%)

NAC (%)

p

All patients (n=192)

13.7
4.1
0.019

Serum creatinine level >2.5 mg/dL (n=20)

45.5
11
0.095

Diabetes (n=98)

8.2
6.1
0.72

LVEF <40% (n=23)

13.3
0
0.23
To download table as a slide, click on slide logo below


Source
  1. N-acetylcysteine versus fenoldopam mesylate to prevent contrast agent-associated nephrotoxicity.2004 Aug 18; 44(4):762-5 





You have to be logged in to add a comment to this article
Login
Username 
Password 
  Forgot your password?
 
Remember me on this computer
 
Join theheart.org community
Five reasons to become a member of the most trusted source of cardiology news:
1Be part of the conversation in our blogs and discussion forum
2Share your thoughts on our news or educational programs
3Receive exclusive newsletters related to your field of interest
4Access unique continuous medical education content
5See and read what leaders have to say about cardiology today
It is free and it only takes five minutes to join!
 
button
Previews
Featured CME