HDL-associated PON1 protein linked to cardiovascular disease
March 18, 2008 | Michael O'Riordan

Cleveland, OH - A new study published this week provides evidence of a mechanistic link between a variant of the paraoxonase 1 (PON1) gene and cardiovascular disease events [1]. Investigators showed that functional PON1 gene polymorphisms promote pronounced systemic antioxidant effects in humans, and these effects translate into reductions in coronary artery disease prevalence and risks of major adverse cardiac events.

"The whole study paints a unified picture that there is a genetic variant in the PON1 gene that encodes for a change that actually determines whether you have a high or low activity of the gene, and we see that this strongly correlates with high or low levels of oxidative stress," said senior investigator Dr Stanley Hazen (Cleveland Clinic, OH). "So, high activity levels of the gene translate into low amounts of oxidative stress, and all of this goes hand in hand with cardiovascular protection."

The results of the study, with lead author Dr Tamali Bhattacharyya (Cleveland Clinic), are published in the March 19, 2008 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association, a special issue devoted to genetics and genomics.


Mixed message from previous meta-analysis

Speaking with heartwire, Hazen explained that PON1 is an HDL-associated protein that "piggybacks" on the HDL particle in the blood and that the PON1 gene has been linked to atherosclerosis protection for more than 10 years. In animals and cell culture, PON1 mediates many of the beneficial effects of HDL cholesterol, such as reducing inflammation and improving reverse transport of cholesterol from the peripheral tissues to the liver. It is also believed to have antioxidative capabilities, but data on atheroprotective effects of the protein in humans, said Hazen, are mixed.

"It's a very interesting protein," said Hazen. "PON1 was first identified as a gene that protects against atherosclerosis in mice models, and it has been linked to atherosclerosis protection for over a decade, but we've been in search of its function. . . . No study has looked at the gene polymorphisms and functional activity and connected this to outcomes data. None has linked all of it together."

One recent meta-analysis of 43 studies examining various single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) for PON1 identified Q192R as the most promising, although the SNP had only a weak overall association with coronary heart disease. It remained to be established whether the genetic and biochemical determinants of PON1 are linked to oxidative stress and cardiovascular disease risk, said Hazen.

To examine the association between PON1 functional activity, such as the anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects, and to determine if the PON1 variant Q192R was associated with a higher rate of cardiovascular disease and major adverse cardiac events, such as MI, stroke, or death, investigators obtained DNA samples from 1399 patients undergoing elective diagnostic coronary angiography between September 2002 and November 2003. Patients were followed until December 2006.


There were significant dose-dependent associations between the PON1 genotype and decreased levels of serum PON1 activity, as well as significant associations between the PON1 variants and increased levels of systemic oxidative stress. Following this, the risk of major adverse cardiac events was significantly lower in participants with the highest amount of PON1 functional activity compared with those in the lowest activity quartile. Investigators also report that the PON1 Q192R polymorphism and serum PON1 activity were associated with coronary artery disease and adverse cardiovascular events over the ensuing three-year follow-up period.

Relationship between PON1 Q192R genotypes and cardiovascular disease outcomes

Outcome
RR192 and QR192 (n=681)
QQ192 (n=584)
p
Nonfatal MI/cerebrovascular accident (%)
7.97
7.88
0.95
Adjusted hazard ratio (95% CI)
1 (reference)
1.01 (0.65-1.57)
0.96
All-cause mortality (%)
6.75
11.10
0.006
Adjusted hazard ratio (95% CI)
1 (reference)
2.05 (1.32-3.18)
0.001
MI, stroke, death
13.59
18.04
0.03
Adjusted hazard ratio (95% CI)
1 (reference)
1.48 (1.09-2.03)
0.01

To download table as a slide, click on slide logo below


"If you have the genotype that encodes a high amount of PON1 activity, you have low oxidative stress, and you have low cardiovascular risk," said Hazen. "Alternatively, if you have the genotype that has very low amounts of activity, you have a high degree of oxidative stress, and you have a substantial increase in risk for experiencing a heart attack or stroke or dying."

Hazen told heartwire that the group also looked at whether knowing the genotype or the biochemical activity, on top of traditional risk factors, added prognostic value. In terms of the ability to predict a major adverse cardiac event, such as heart attack, stroke, or death, the PON1 variants and activity levels both predicted adverse events above and beyond traditional risk factors, he said. Even among those with no known history of cardiovascular disease, high levels of PON1 activity translated into an increased risk of cardiovascular events, he added.

Hazen reports that he is the scientific founder of PrognostiX, a laboratory focused on proprietary tests, including testing for myeloperoxidase. He also reports having received grant support, research, and consulting fees from numerous pharmaceutical companies.

Source
  1. Bhattacharyya T, Nicholls SJ, Topol EJ, et al. Relationship of paraoxonase 1 (PON1) gene polymorphisms and functional activity with systemic oxidative stress and cardiovascular risk. JAMA 2008; 299:1265-1276. Available at: http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/299/11/1265.



Your comments
HDL-associated PON1 protein linked to cardiovascular disease
# 1 of 8
March 19, 2008 09:59 (EDT)
DONNA GLASKY
Probucol
Has anyone looked into probucol and its association with PON1?
# 2 of 8
March 20, 2008 01:47 (EDT)
CJ Mc
There is data on niacin,..
PON1 is most abundant when the phenotype of the HDL subclasses is predominantly large [HDL2b]. Dysfunctional HDL often is laden with SAA [Amyloid] attached to it and very little PON1 activity. It is an indirect effect, but nevertheless, an effect most robustly seen with niacin therapy. Fibrates LOWER HDL2 & none of the other lipid drugs have much effect there; pioglitazone, krill oil at least appear to have some benefit as per increasing the large functional HDL`s & subsequently PON1.
# 3 of 8
March 20, 2008 11:25 (EDT)
D Hackam
Fibrates LOWER HDL2
Maybe this is why there is so little hard event data for fibrates being positive -- ie FIELD, BIP, LEADER, etc, have all been negative (at least for fenofibrate and bezafibrate).
# 4 of 8
March 22, 2008 10:55 (EDT)
Michael Cobble, M.D.
fibrates
Dan, I would disagree somewhat about failed studies and also HDL2. Studies have shown low hdl2, hdl3,high hdl2, hdl3 to beth be preventive and increase risk in nature. The functionality, the ability to retain HDL are all very important. For those with endothelial dysfunction or urine MA or kidney disease (htn, dm, tob induced etc) HDL3 can be lost rapidly and may not have their protective properties. Much speculation at this time about whether hdl2 or hdl3 or some ratio of the two is better. We do know that people can have nonfunctional HDL the issue is - How do we know?

TG's by themselves may not be atherogenic unless combined with low hdl or small dense LDL or nhdl remnants, thus TG studies can have a dilution factor. BIP showed strong risk association when you looked at the over 1000 pts with Met Syn and the NNT was dramatic 18-24 as good or better than almost all statin studies. FIELD feno/statin vs. placebo/statin was also powerful when looking at this very low risk diabetic population and yet statistical reductions in macro and micro events were seen.

One should still have 'all' DM pts on a statin if possible and add feno if tg/hdl reductions are needed to reach goal or add niacin if hdl/tg reductions or add both. The latter is most helpful if one needs mechanistic changes in lipoprotein lipase, hepatic lipase and DGAT. Lowering the oxidation potential of LDL, VLDL and IDL..
# 5 of 8
March 22, 2008 11:35 (EDT)
D Hackam
perils of subgroup analyses
The exciting BIP finding, and that of VA-HIT, HHS, etc - namely that metsyn patients respond much better to fibrates - was never verified prospectively in FIELD. Small subgroup analyses, even n>1000, have to be considered hypothesis-generating and subject to verification prospectively in future RCTs. There are multiple reasons for type I and II error in subgroup analyses -- 1) smaller sample size (thereby limiting precision); 2) smaller sample size (thereby increasing chance of spurious false positive findings); 3) investigator bias from selectively reporting and publishing positive subgroup analyses; 4) multiple hypothesis testing, data-mining, data-dredging.

Overall most fibrate trials fail to show benefit. Low HDL is a strong predictor of increased benefit from statin trials seen in many studies. I would hope that people would reach for a statin rather than a fibrate in patients with low HDL first.
# 6 of 8
March 22, 2008 04:30 (EDT)
Michael Cobble, M.D.
reach for a statin
the point and supported by multiple evidence based studies is if someone has low hdl - their clinician should reach for a combination lipid agent which includes a statin. combinations are way underutilized in pts with mixed dyslipidemia, low hdl and tg's as well as high risk chd pts.

Combination lipid mgmt needs better utilization.
# 7 of 8
March 28, 2008 09:09 (EDT)
CJ Mc
Statin + niacin ove statin + fibrate
The EBM data on the niacin combo far outweighs that with fibrates: CDP, CDP-15 yr, CLAS-I, CLAS-II, SCOR. FATS, FATS f/u, HATS, AFREGS, ARBITER 2 & #. Also, just from a surrogate marker stance, if lipid-fractions are being measured it is rather dramatc what occurs over 12 months, then 24 months & 36 months with continued niacin use. Slow, but inexorable shifts. Just doesn`t happen with fibrates. Fish oil [or krill oil/NKO] are really nice as well if elevated trigs are a concern. 2 gms IR or ER niacin plus 6 gms fish oil added to a statin have guite a profound effect on all the TGRLs, incl. VLDL3 & pattern size/density/particle number. Lp(a) usually takes a year or two to drop. The more that triple-combo is ustilized, the less useful the fibrates appear. The EBM on omega`s & niacin really underscores that thinking as well vs fibrates.
# 8 of 8
March 28, 2008 01:29 (EDT)
D Hackam
niacin tolerability
I agree with CJ that niacin data is better than fibrate data (with the exception with gemfibrozil, which I am reluctant to combine with most of the statins in light of what happened with rhabdomyolysis deaths with the demise of Baycol). However, most patients have major problems tolerating niacin, let alone statins, and the counselling and titration needed is a real headache. My main goal is to maximize statin dose first and foremost and then combine with other agents. In numerous statin trials it seems that both relative risk reductions and absolute risk reductions are intensified in patients with low HDL and/or high trigs. Therefore, even if the drug is not having that much biochemical effect on surrogate markers such as the lipid panel, we still know it is having a greater event reduction. Bob Rosenbaum has made this point in a beautiful review article last year in Am Heart J.

You have to be logged in to add a comment to this article
Login
Username 
Password 
  Forgot your password?
 
Remember me on this computer
 
Join theheart.org community
Five reasons to become a member of the most trusted source of cardiology news:
1Be part of the conversation in our blogs and discussion forum
2Share your thoughts on our news or educational programs
3Receive exclusive newsletters related to your field of interest
4Access unique continuous medical education content
5See and read what leaders have to say about cardiology today
It is free and it only takes five minutes to join!
 
button
Previews
Featured CME