Prevention
Simple dental workup reverses atherosclerotic lesions
December 19, 2008 | Lisa Nainggolan

Milan, Italy - For the first time, researchers have shown that treating mild to moderate gum disease in otherwise-healthy volunteers improves endothelial dysfunction and significantly reduces carotid intima media thickness (IMT), as measured by echo Doppler [1]. The report, by Dr Stefania Piconi (Hospital Luigi Sacco, Milan, Italy) and colleagues, was published online December 12, 2008 in the FASEB Journal, the publication of the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology.

"The novelty of this study is that this is the first physical evidence that you can reverse a lesion that is already growing in the intima by doing something as simple as taking care of your gums," immunologist and senior author Dr Mario Clerici (University of Milan, Italy) told heartwire. "To tell you the truth, we were really surprised by the result, but it turned up in subject after subject."

To tell you the truth, we were really surprised by the result, but it turned up in subject after subject.

Clerici stressed, however, that their sample size was small—just 35 individuals—so his team are now repeating the study with a couple of hundred people, this time spanning a wider spectrum of periodontal disease, from mild to quite severe. "We have also included patients with frank atherosclerosis," he noted, "because we want to see whether—if people have a really big, solid plaque—we can modify that as well. We want to confirm and extend our results. That's what we are doing now."

Dr Maurizio Tonetti (European Research Group on Periodontology, Berne, Switzerland), a periodontist with an interest in this field who was not involved with this research, told heartwire: "The data are consistent with current hypotheses that periodontitis is a cause of systemic inflammation and contributes to early atherosclerosis. [But] no conclusions can be drawn from this pilot study. Properly sized randomized clinical trials are needed to establish whether periodontitis can be considered a contributing cause of atherosclerosis."


Simple removal of tartar and cleaning is all that's required

Clerici explained to heartwire that many previous studies have established a correlation between dental health and the genesis of atherosclerosis; in particular, the bacteria Porphyromonas gingivalis has been associated with the development of atherosclerotic plaques.

Previous research has shown that by improving dental health, markers such as lymphocytes, monocytes, and C-reactive protein are reduced, he said, "but there has never been any demonstration of changes that can be picked up by echo Doppler."

He and his colleagues enrolled 35 otherwise-healthy individuals, with median age of 46 years, affected by mild to moderate periodontal disease who underwent treatment in their longitudinal study. This was "totally simple," said Clerici, "it involved removal of tartar and cleaning the gums, and that's it—no surgery and no antibiotics—just your basic dental hygiene."

It involved . . . no surgery and no antibioticsjust your basic dental hygiene.

Echo Doppler cardiography of the carotid artery was performed at baseline and at various time points after periodontal treatment, as was evaluation of inflammatory markers involved in the atherogenic process and surrogate markers of cardiovascular risk and carotid IMT.

Inflammation biomarkers were abnormally increased at baseline, and periodontal treatment resulted in a significant reduction in the total oral bacterial load, which was associated with a significant amelioration of inflammation biomarkers and adhesion and activation proteins, the researchers explain.


IMT reduced at various sites along carotid axis

Notably, IMT was significantly diminished after treatment. The reduction was observed as early as six months after treatment, persisted throughout the study period, and could be detected in multiple sites along the carotid axis.

Changes in carotid IMT, by site, from baseline and after treatment

Site of carotid IMT measurement (median)
At baseline (mm)
6 mo after treatment (mm)
12 mo after treatment (mm)
p (12 mo vs baseline)
At carotid bifurcation
0.55
0.40
0.45
0.01
1 cm from carotid bifurcation
0.49
0.38
0.37
<0.001
2 cm from carotid bifurcation
0.50
0.42
0.39
0.001

To download table as a slide, click on slide logo above

In conclusion, Clerici said that if their follow-up studies are successful, the take-home message will be: "By taking good care of your teeth and gums, you can not only prevent the development of atherosclerosis, you can also reduce your risk of developing cardiovascular disease."

Tonetti agrees: "Randomized trials are needed, since periodontitis is highly prevalent but easily preventable and treatable. If the relationship were indeed causal, better oral health could greatly contribute to the prevention of atherosclerosis in the population."

Source
  1. Piconi S, Trabattoni D, Luraghi C et al. Treatment of periodontal disease results in improvements in endothelial dysfunction and reduction of the carotid intima-media thickness. FASEB J 2008; DOI: 10.1096/fj.08-119578. Available at http://www.fasebj.org.



Your comments
Simple dental workup reverses atherosclerotic lesions
# 1 of 8
December 22, 2008 10:05 (EST)
Melissa Walton-Shirley
Another reason why Kentucky, Virginia and North Carolina , .........
states where tobacco use is among the highest in the industrialized world demonstrate the highest levels of early onset coronary artery disease. Not only are we less educated, but we have the fewest teeth per capita because family monetary resources are squandered on cigarettes.
Congratulations to Governor Beshear and the other tobacco growing states for pushing for higher cigarette taxes. Contact your state representatives and senators to encourage them to step outside the box and vote to pass this very important legislation for your state along with a state smoke free ordinace.
We'll only have success when push really does come to shove!
Melissa
# 2 of 8
December 23, 2008 09:24 (EST)
Michael Cobble, M.D.
Interesting
Melissa, I thought this was a very interesting article. Fewest teeth per capita is a very distressing statistic. I don't like to 'scare' my patients away from tobacco, but we do let them know in their 30-40's they will start losing teeth and have wrinkling of skin followed by increased risk for heart attacks, strokes, cancer and oxygen dependent emphysema. We are here to help any way we can them remove all tobacco from their life. etc...
# 3 of 8
December 23, 2008 10:15 (EST)
Wiliam Blanchet
Remarkable
Amazing that dental hygiene can do what high dose lipitor and vytorin are incapable of doing, i.e. reduce CIMT! Looks like another major modifiable risk factor to evaluate with coronary prevention.

I guess I had better go floss, right after I finish my hibiscus tea and before I spend 30 minutes on the treadmill.

I agree with Melissa, it is way past time to end the culture of cigarette smoking. Yet one more reason. Every time is see a vigorous, healthy young person smoking, I ache quietly.
# 4 of 8
December 23, 2008 12:40 (EST)
Jeff Booth
cart or horse?
For non-smoking patients is periodontal disease then a marker for potential systemic inflammation, suggesting additional tests (the dental disease just another manifestation), or is there really a true causal link from the dental disease to systemic atherosclerosis?
# 5 of 8
December 23, 2008 02:02 (EST)
D Hackam
"what high dose lipitor and vytorin are incapable of doing, i.e. reduce CIMT! "
Anyone who does not believe that high dose statins, including atorvastatin at 80 mg/d, does not reduce CIMT or plaque burden must not be aware of numerous studies including ASAP, REVERSAL, as well as clinical outcome studies such as MIRACL, TNT, SPARCL, IDEAL, PROVE-IT, and others.

We find that boosting the statin dose to 80 mg often markedly regresses plaque burden on ultrasound.

It is funny how one can believe a small observational study and not a wealth of randomized data. This is clearly a bias.
# 6 of 8
December 23, 2008 04:43 (EST)
Maurizio Battino
Periodontal disease as a marker of systemic inflammation
That's nothing surprising in this paper: in the last 10 years, we have been stressing the concept that periodontitis may be a priviledged situation for preventive purposes in several systemic diseases directly or indirectly linked to inflamatory burden (i.e., diabetes, obesity, atherosclerosis, metabolic syndrome).
Oxidative stress may represent the actual link between periodontal derangement and systemic diseases.
If you are interested in these topics I can suggest to check the next issues of Journal of Dental Research (e.g. Spring 2009) since an exhaustive review will appear discussing such aspects.
The authors of this forthcoming review are Bullon, Morillo, Quiles, Ramirez-Tortosa, Newman and Battino.
Otherwise you can contact me at m.a.battino@univpm.it for further information.
# 7 of 8
December 30, 2008 02:09 (EST)
Wiliam Blanchet
"what high dose lipitor and vytorin are incapable of doing, i.e. reduce CIMT! "
Dan, I am surprised by your sensitivity toward statins. I don't think they need your defense. The fact that you find increasing statins to max doses reduces plaque by US is great. I am more interested in when it prevents heart attacks rather than when it makes the ultrasound look better. 80 mg of lipitor still only prevents 40% of heart attacks. Where I went to school, a 40% was a low F.

Virtually all studies on statins demonstrate decrease in progression of CIMT, not reversal. This study reports reversal. I stand by my observation.

I am all too aware of the statin studies, especially the part that shows that statins alone prevent a minority of events. Despite this overwhelming DATA, the experts still promote statins as the only treatment needed in a majority of subjects.

I will admit a bias. I am biased toward therapies that prevent a majority of heart attacks. I am biased against the self promotion that we see from our major academic institutions for their marginal technologies such as IVUS and HSCRP.

It is not my lack of acquaintance with the literature that makes me biased, it is my intimate familiarity with it that creates my opinion. Perhaps a little more critical reading of the studies you quoted would be called for. In none of the studies you quote did the treatment prevent more than a minority of events!
# 8 of 8
December 30, 2008 10:14 (EST)
steven tatar
Cimt standardization, where are we?
Enhance failed miserably in part because of lack of consistancy in cimt measurement (some measurements were simply biologically unlikely).

The Chicago pio cimt study solved the problem by having one reader only.

Locally I have used 2 centers with > one decade of reading experience and they seem to replicate each others' readings. I rarely find, if ever, a reading of < 0.6mm thickness in my primary prevention patients, even in the healthy 45 year old.

Rates of cimt change are glacial. Even in patients with great residual risk progression is usually less than 0.05mm/year.

Regression is uncommonly achieved even with extraordinary treatment of all risk factors. Even HDL Milano infusion achieved ? was it 4% regression in statin naive acute coronary syndrome patients after 6 weekly infusions? ASAP managed regression only from 0.91mm to 0.87 with lipitor 80 in statin naive pts with ldl>300.

So I do find it implausible that normal individuals in this study showed 20% cimt regression (0.5mm --> 0.4mm) with nothing but a few gingival cleanings in 6 months.


You have to be logged in to add a comment to this article
Login
Username 
Password 
  Forgot your password?
 
Remember me on this computer
 
Join theheart.org community
Five reasons to become a member of the most trusted source of cardiology news:
1Be part of the conversation in our blogs and discussion forum
2Share your thoughts on our news or educational programs
3Receive exclusive newsletters related to your field of interest
4Access unique continuous medical education content
5See and read what leaders have to say about cardiology today
It is free and it only takes five minutes to join!
 
button
Previews
Featured CME
Inside: Prevention