Robotic surgery is going mainstream: Watch for healthcare costs to skyrocket

Aug 25, 2010 09:35 EDT


In their recent paper, Drs Gabriel I Barbash and Sherry A Glied report on an important rise in healthcare costs due to the increasing adoption of robotic surgery. They pose a fundamental question: why adopt new technologies that have not been validated by randomized clinical trials, appear to offer no advantage to patient outcomes, and are more expensive than existing procedures?

What are your thoughts on robotic surgery? Important trail-blazing technology or unnecessary, not yet validated, and a driver of healthcare costs?

See:

Barbash GI, Glied SA. New technology and health care costs: The case of robot-assisted surgery. N Engl J Med 2010; 363:701-704. Available here.

Clinicians use robot to perform EP diagnostics and ablate atrial flutter








Your comments
Robotic surgery is going mainstream: Watch for healthcare costs to skyrocket
# 1 of 2
August 27, 2010 03:14 (EDT)
Jai Raman

We had the unique opportunity of utilizing the services of Dr Sudhir Srivastava for 18 months - he had his own Hospital in Odessa, Texas where he learnt to work with the Da Vinci robot extensively and he is acknowledged as the leading performer of Totally Endoscopic Coronary Artery Bypass (TECAB)graft surgery.  The peri-operative results in the 1st 100 patients was not highly encouraging - in a relatively low risk population, there was a significant morbidity rate and a few deaths.  This is despite a surgeon who was very facilte with the robot and his team helping him. The technology is just not there - at least for cardiac surgery.  I perform all my valve through small incisions and selected CABG through a left mini-thoracotomy for a fraction of the cost and a fraction of the time - the patients seem to do better than those that underwent robotic procedures.

 

 

# 2 of 2
August 27, 2010 08:58 (EDT)
Eric Topol
Thanks for sharing this, Jai...invaluable perspective

You must be a member (with full membership) to post a comment.
Already a member?
Enter your login information below:
 Remember me on this computer
Enjoy all the benefits of theheart.org

With full membership, you can check out our educational and editorial content, search the site, receive our newsletters, join discussions, download slides and much more.

Membership is free!